This hilarious Thanksgiving game for families will have people trying to match their partner in random Thanksgiving questions to earn points and win the game! The partners change every question so everyone always has a shot to win and as a bonus, you get to talk to and play with different people every time!
We played this one with my extended family and it was hilarious to watch what answers people came up with and how far apart some people’s brains were, and how sure everyone was that their answer was the only right one!

A Thanksgiving Game for Large Groups
I’ve been in charge of our Thanksgiving games for as long as I can remember. My entire family lives in one place so every year I come up with new Thanksgiving games so we’re not just playing the same game every year.
This year I thought it’d be fun to do a play on the Newlywed game with pairs having to answer questions and try to match each other but instead of just having a few people play, turn it into something that everyone could play at the same time!
The name Newlyfed game is a play on Newlywed (that my sister actually came up with) and ideally you’d play this after you eat – so everyone is literally just fed, or newly fed.
We originally played around with the idea of everyone just picking one partner for the entire game but realized that may not make this game fun for everyone. There are some people, like married couples, who may have a much easier time matching than say a friend who came to Thanksgiving as a guest.
So instead everyone switches partners every single round. Not only does it make it way more fun, it also turns this into a more interactive game that encourages mingling and talking to people other than just your close friends! We did it with a group of 20, and it was so much fun!
Who Will Love This Game
- Ages 8+ – there are 63 different question cards and you can easily choose questions that anyone can answer but you do need to be able to write their own answer, so probably ages 8+. Younger kids could definitely team up with their parents!
- Any size group – you can really play this with any number of people from 4 to 24. It’s definitely more fun with at least 8 people so you are switching and matching with various people, but it’s really doable with any size!
- People who like easy games – this one is laid-back, easy to play, and no real thinking after the turkey game. That’s why it’s one of my favorites!
Supplies for the Newlyfed Game
- Dry erase boards – I grabbed a set of boards that came with small dry erase boards, markers, and erasers. It was perfect, and I use it all the time for all sorts of different games! You could also just give everyone a piece of paper, it’s just not nearly as fun as having something big to turn over.
- Question cards – you can download the questions at the end of this post. I’ve created a set of 63 questions that encourage answers but don’t point people to one specific answer.
- Prizes – I recommend some sort of food related prize for the winner of this one. It should just be one winner but if you have a tie, I’ve included some tie breaker questions below that you can use to choose an ultimate winner!

How to Setup the Game
This game is really easy to setup, which is why it’s one of my favorite new Thanksgiving games!
Print out the cards that you want to use from the set provided at the bottom of this post.
Give everyone a dry erase board, a marker, and an eraser (or a paper towel works too). Then everyone chooses a partner for the first round, they’ll need to sit either back to back with their partner or somewhere that they won’t be able to see each other’s boards.
Then you’re ready to start playing!

How to play the newlyfed Game
Once everyone has chosen a partner for the first round, choose one of the cards and ask your first question. Everyone writes down their answer with the goal being to match their partner.
Give everyone like 10-15 seconds to write something down, so the game moves quickly. Make sure everyone has finished writing their answers then go around the room and have pairs flip over their answers to see if they matched.

If they match, they give themselves a point. We all kept track just with tally marks on the dry erase boards but if you want to keep track on a big scorecard, feel free.
Keep going around the room until all of the pairs have shown their answers and tallied their points. Then everyone chooses a new partner for the next question – no repeating partners until you’ve already been with everyone else (within reason, don’t make a huge deal out of it, the goal is just to mix things up).

Ask the next question and that new set of partners writes down their answer and tries to match their new partner. Go through answers again, score points, and then switch partners again for the next question.

Keep going through as many questions as you want. I like to set a predetermined number ahead of time and tell people so they know where they’re sitting score-wise with how many questions left. Once you’ve asked all of the questions, everyone counts up their final score (individuals, not pairs) and the person with the most points at the end of the game wins.
How to Win
The game ends once you’ve gone through all of the questions you want to ask and the person with the most individual points at the end wins.
If there’s a tie with two people having the same number of points, you can use the following tie breakers below to choose a winner! Ask them to guess the answer and whoever is closest wins!
Alternate Variations
If you think the switching partners part of this game is going to be too chaotic or too much movement for your group (if you have a lot of elderly family members playing for example), you can absolutely just choose one partner to try and match for the entire game.
If you do go with just one partner for the entire game, you’ll need two prizes for the winning pair versus just one for the individual winner!

Prize ideas
Since this game is called the Newlyfed game, I recommend doing a prize that is food related in some way. You can always do a gift card to a restaurant or something like DoorDash or if you want to get more creative, these are some fun food related prizes:
- Foodie dice – make choosing dinner easier with these fun dice!
- Fast food socks – these hilarious socks come in a fast food box and are so fun!
- Fun cooking tool – there are a bunch of different tools that will not only be fun to use but would make funny gifts!
- Gourmet snack like this jerky – you could also do fancy salts, hot sauces, or really any snack food!
- Burrito blanket – or any other funny food item would be a great prize too!
Game FAQs
Do you have to switch partners every question?
If you’d prefer to not switch partners every question, you can play with the same pair every time. We tried both ways and found it to be a lot more fun switching partners and having to try and match different people. It also made it more fun for the people who might not have a long-term partner or someone they would easily match all the questions with. Choose based on your group!
How many questions should I ask?
I found 15 questions was a good amount to keep the game short enough to still be engaging but long enough to give people a chance to score higher than the other players and have some division in the scores. It also let me choose some good variety in the questions without a ton of overlap.
What if we have an odd number of people?
Every time there will be one group with three people and all three have to match to get the points. The three person group should switch every time so no one is at a disadvantage every time.
Helpful Tips
Keep the game moving. Only give people 10-15 seconds to write down an answer. The goal is to write down answers quickly. This will keep things fun, fast, and interactive for everyone.
If you stick with one partner instead of switching, I recommend choosing either random partnerships, mixing up families, or pairing adults + teens together to keep things fair.
Mix up the questions so you’re not doing just food questions, TV show questions, etc. A variety of questions will make this more fun!
More Thanksgiving Games
If you like this Newlyfed game, you have to try these other Thanksgiving games too!
- Thanksgiving family feud – fun questions to play your own version of Family Feud at home!
- Thanksgiving Jeopardy – over 60 fun Thanksgiving themed questions to play a classic game of Jeopardy!
- Thanksgiving floor game – if you’ve ever seen the game show, this is a Thanksgiving version you can play at home!
- Get a turkey – a fun Thanksgiving dice game for the entire family!
- Thanksgiving would you rather – silly questions to ask each other with Thanksgiving inspiration!

want more Thanksgiving Games?
Download the Printable Newlyfed Cards
Enter your first name and email address in the form below to get the free printable PDF. You will receive a link to download the PDF to your email within minutes. Print on card stock and you’re on your way.
If you’d prefer to not provide your email address, you can get a copy in my shop here.
If you do not see the form, click here to get to it.
If you do not see the email with the printable design templates immediately after you fill out the form, make sure to check your promotions, spam, and junk folders!
The file will include:
- Newlyfed cards
- Use policy (everything is for personal use only)













Leave a Reply